Residence & CitizenshipEntry PF-669583 · Page 16 · Stamped NOV 15, 2026
Canada Holds PR Applications for Would-Be Citizens by Descent
Bill C-3, in force December 15, 2025, lets IRCC hold PR applications when an officer believes the applicant is already a citizen by descent — a 34-month certificate process decides the outcome.
- Programme
- Residence & Citizenship
- Filed
- Reading
- 3 min
Entry details
- Bill C-3, removing the first-generation limit on citizenship by descent, came into force on December 15, 2025.
- IRCC's published processing time for proof of citizenship is 34 months as of October 2026.
- Children born on or after December 15, 2025 require a Canadian parent with 1,095 days of physical presence in Canada.
- Spousal sponsorship outside Canada and Quebec takes about 18 months; Express Entry runs closer to seven months.
- Citizenship confirmed means the PR application is considered withdrawn; no claim means it returns to its original queue position.
Canada's immigration department can place a permanent residence application on hold whenever an officer believes the applicant is already a Canadian citizen, under rules that changed on December 15, 2025. The trigger is Bill C-3, an amendment to the Citizenship Act that removed the first-generation limit on citizenship by descent.
Briannah Dale, senior communications adviser at Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC), told CBC News that the department cannot say how many PR applications it has put on hold because the applicant may also qualify for citizenship.
Who counts as a citizen by descent?
People born before December 15, 2025 who can trace an unbroken line of descent to a Canadian ancestor may already be citizens by descent — often without knowing it. A Canadian grandparent alone does not guarantee the status. The ancestor must have been a citizen when the next generation was born, and the line of descent must contain no breaks.
Children born on or after December 15, 2025 face an extra requirement: the Canadian parent must show at least 1,095 days — three years — of cumulative physical presence in Canada before the child's birth or adoption. Spouses are not covered; citizenship follows descent and adoption, not marriage.
What happens if a person applies for both PR and citizenship?
Dale explained the sequence to CBC News: if someone applies for proof of citizenship while also applying for PR, the PR application is placed on hold while the concurrent citizenship application is assessed.
"If citizenship is confirmed, the permanent residence application will be considered withdrawn. If citizenship is not confirmed, the permanent residence application will return to its original place in the processing queue and resume processing."
An officer can also pause a PR application even where no citizenship certificate has been requested, if the officer has "compelling reasons to believe an applicant may already be a citizen under Canadian law."
A separate IRCC response, published by immigration lawyer Steven Meurrens from the department's Immigration Representatives Mailbox, states the underlying principle: "A person with a claim to citizenship is presumed Canadian through automatic operation of law and ineligible for immigration documents such as a permanent resident visa."
That mailbox response describes the process differently: applicants with a pending PR application "will be contacted by IRCC to withdraw their immigration application and submit an application for Proof of Citizenship." Whether a file is withdrawn or merely paused remains unclear and may depend on the officer handling it. The mailbox notes it gives general guidance, not case-specific answers.
In plain terms: a person with a valid citizenship claim cannot obtain permanent residence at all.
What do the timelines look like?
- Proof of citizenship: 34 months, as of IRCC's published processing time for October 2026, subject to change.
- Spousal sponsorship from outside Canada and outside Quebec: about 18 months.
- Express Entry skilled worker processing: closer to seven months.
The immigration route looks faster on paper. But IRCC states that a person who qualifies for citizenship by descent is not eligible for a PR document. The two statuses also differ in kind: a citizenship certificate confirms existing citizenship, with no physical presence requirement, no citizenship test and no oath ceremony — all of which apply to those seeking citizenship through permanent residence.
Dale added that those who already hold permanent resident status will not lose it while waiting for a citizenship certificate.
Where that leaves applicants
Anyone with a suspected Canadian ancestor and an immigration application in progress may benefit from resolving the citizenship question first, since a genuine claim makes the immigration route unavailable. Applicants who turn out not to have a claim return to their original place in the queue.
Clues worth researching include an ancestor born in a Canadian province, a family that spoke French at home, a French surname, or roots in New England. None of these confirms a claim; they indicate which branch of the family tree to research. IRCC advises that applicants who believe they may have a claim must submit an application for a citizenship certificate.
One line summarizes the rule: Canada will not grant permanent residence to someone the law already treats as a citizen.
via cicnews.com (Source)
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Correspondent covering regulation, policy and their impact on Immigration and mobility policy worldwide at Passport File.
365 articles