Residence & CitizenshipEntry PF-606106 · Page 43 · Stamped NOV 14, 2026
UK Doubles Settlement Wait to 20 Years; Blind Pensioner Told to 'Go Home' to India
A blind Nigerian pensioner in the UK for 26 years was told to return to India — a country she has never visited — as settlement wait times double under rules by Shabana Mahmood.
- Programme
- Residence & Citizenship
- Filed
- Reading
- 4 min

Entry details
- New UK settlement rules announced by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood extend renewal periods from 10 to 20 years for long-residence applicants.
- Comfort, 67, blind and resident in the UK since 2000, was refused fast-tracked indefinite leave to remain and told she could return to India, a country she has never visited.
- FOI data obtained by Refugee and Migrant Justice includes a 103-year-old applicant from Pakistan who will not qualify for settlement until age 123.
- For some applicants, the settlement waiting period has increased sixfold under the new rules.
- Home Office sources said a corrected refusal letter is being re-issued.
A blind 67-year-old Nigerian woman who has lived in the United Kingdom for 26 years received a Home Office refusal letter telling her she could safely return to India — a country she says she has never visited. The letter, issued under settlement rules announced this week by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, has forced lawyers into damage control, and Home Office sources now say an updated letter is being re-issued.
Who is affected by the change?
The woman, identified only as Comfort because her name has been changed, arrived in the UK in 2000. She went blind shortly after arrival due to acute glaucoma. In 2022, after two decades in the country, she received permission to stay under the long residence route.
That route previously required renewals every 30 months for 10 years before a person could apply for indefinite leave to remain. Under the new settlement framework announced by Shabana Mahmood, the qualifying period effectively doubles. Comfort now faces roughly 20 more years of renewals; she would reach her 80s before she becomes eligible for settlement.
What did the Home Office actually say?
Lawyers at Refugee and Migrant Justice asked the Home Office to fast-track indefinite leave to remain, citing a provision that permits exceptional circumstances. The department refused.
The first part of the letter suggested she could return to Nigeria because services exist there for blind people. The letter then concluded: "Your circumstances are not so severe or lacking in potential treatment in India that it would warrant indefinite leave to remain in this case."
The reference to India — for a Nigerian national — is the error the Home Office now concedes. Sources said corrective action is under way to re-issue an updated letter.
A Home Office spokesperson said: "We do not routinely comment on individual cases. All applications for permission to stay in the UK are carefully considered on their individual merits, in line with the immigration rules and based on the information and evidence provided by the applicant."
The statement addresses process. It does not address the doubled wait times, the erroneous country reference, or the pending review of Comfort's own case.
How long will others wait?
Migrants' rights organisations have challenged the lengthened settlement timelines. For some applicants, the waiting period has increased sixfold under the new rules.
Freedom of information data obtained by Refugee and Migrant Justice shows that many applicants of pensionable age are likely to die before they satisfy the new wait times. One disclosed case involves a 103-year-old woman from Pakistan who will not become eligible for settlement until she is 123 years old.
What did Comfort say?
"In 2022, I got my permission to stay here based on long residence in the UK," Comfort said. "I'm very disheartened that I may now need to wait nearly 20 years to get indefinite leave to remain."
"I have been living in this country for 26 years. I have found my home here and settled well. I have my friends, my church and do voluntary work. I'm a good citizen, not a law-breaker and am begging the Home Office to have mercy on me and grant me indefinite leave to remain now, rather than making me wait 20 more years."
She added: "I don't know why the Home Office said I could go back to India. It's a country I have never visited and have no connection with."
What do campaigners argue?
Nick Beales, head of campaigning at Migrant and Refugee Justice, said: "This woman is blind, in her late 60s and has lived in the UK for a quarter of a century. She meets the rules to remain here and there is no public interest in making her continue to renew her visa."
"Rather than viewing these vulnerable people as human beings, the government is fixated on appearing tough. Shabana Mahmood's plans to double settlement routes will clearly make these problems even worse, especially as her decision-makers cannot even differentiate between India and Nigeria."
Beales also pointed to the FOI data: "Government data shows that people over 80 are applying to enter these settlement routes. While it's unlikely many of these people would survive a 10-year period, Mahmood has not explained what she hopes to achieve by making these octogenarians and older wait two decades before having settlement."
His organisation has called on the government to admit the earned settlement model is, in his words, "cruel and counter-productive" and to scrap the plans entirely. The Home Office has not responded to that call, and no revised figures on expected settlement timelines have been published.
What happens next?
The corrected letter will be re-issued, according to Home Office sources. Comfort's request for immediate indefinite leave to remain remains refused as matters stand, and she faces repeated 30-month renewals for the next two decades unless the policy changes or the department exercises its exceptional-circumstances provision.
via theguardian.com (Source)
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering regulation, policy and their impact on Immigration and mobility policy worldwide at Passport File.
365 articles