Asylum & ProtectionEntry PF-706962 · Page 03 · Stamped NOV 12, 2026
UK Earned Settlement Plan Alarms Refugees Already on Five-Year Route
A 3 November UK briefing moves pre-2 March 2026 asylum claimants to 30-month permission, alarming refugees who held a promised five-year settlement route.
- Programme
- Asylum & Protection
- Filed
- Reading
- 3 min

Entry details
- UK policy briefing published 3 November 2025 sets 2 March 2026 as the cut-off for moving asylum claimants to 30-month core protection permission.
- Home secretary announced the earned settlement policy on 4 November without clarifying whether existing five-year refugee permission holders are affected.
- Letter writer claimed asylum in 2007, won his appeal in February 2020, and received five-year refugee permission only in June 2022 after Home Office delays.
- His June 2025 indefinite leave to remain application was refused; he expected to reapply in June 2027.
- The family includes three UK-born children, two British citizens, and has not left the UK in nearly 19 years.
A UK government briefing published on 3 November states that people who claimed asylum before 2 March 2026 will move into a new "core protection" system and receive permission to stay for 30 months at a time, replacing the five-year route to settlement that existing refugees were previously told they would keep. The home secretary announced the wider earned settlement policy on 4 November, and refugee families say the change has thrown their long-term status into doubt.
What does the new policy change?
Under the earned settlement plan, protection would no longer lead automatically to settlement after five years of continuous refugee permission. Instead, the 3 November briefing indicates the government intends to transfer people who claimed asylum before the 2 March 2026 cut-off into the core protection system, issuing permission in 30-month increments.
The briefing, reported on 4 November, did not clearly state whether refugees who already hold five-year refugee permission will be affected. That silence is the source of the distress now spreading among settled refugee families, according to a letter published in a national newspaper by a refugee writing under name and address withheld.
The central question is transitional: people granted refugee status under the old rules relied on a stated five-year path to settlement, and the new plan does not confirm whether that promise still stands.
Who has come forward?
The letter writer, a refugee living in the UK since 2007, described a case that shows how Home Office delays interact with the new policy. He claimed asylum in 2007 and won his appeal at the first-tier tribunal, immigration and asylum chamber, in February 2020. Home Office delays meant he did not receive his five-year refugee permission until June 2022.
He applied for indefinite leave to remain in June 2025. The Home Office refused the application because five years had not passed from the date his refugee permission was granted. He expected to reapply in June 2027.
The letter poses the question directly: "How is it fair to change the settlement rules for people who have already been granted five years of refugee permission and have spent years waiting for security and stability?"
What is at stake for affected families?
The writer's household illustrates the stakes. His wife is also a refugee. The couple have three children born in the UK, two of whom hold British citizenship. The family has not left the UK in nearly 19 years. The writer has faced serious health problems, including cancer, and remains under specialist hospital care.
"We understand that immigration rules can change," the letter states, "but people who have already been granted refugee status should not be left uncertain about promises and expectations they relied on."
The family says the uncertainty over their future is causing considerable stress.
What happens next?
Key dates frame the dispute:
- 2 March 2026 — the cut-off in the briefing; claims made before this date would move into core protection with 30-month permission periods.
- 3 November — publication of the policy briefing describing the new system.
- 4 November — the home secretary's announcement of the earned settlement policy, which did not clarify the position of existing five-year permission holders.
- June 2027 — the date the letter writer expected to reapply for indefinite leave to remain after his June 2025 refusal.
The home secretary's statement left open the question of whether refugees with existing five-year permission keep their route to settlement. Until the government clarifies the transitional arrangements, families granted status under the old rules face continued uncertainty about whether the five-year settlement promise applies to them.
Affected readers should track formal Home Office guidance as it is published; the 3 November briefing and the 4 November statement remain the official anchors of the change.
via theguardian.com (Source)
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Correspondent covering regulation, policy and their impact on Immigration and mobility policy worldwide at Passport File.
365 articles